no third solution

Blogging about liberty, anarchy, economics and politics

If You Don’t Like It – Get the Fuck Out!

June 27th, 2007

Update: If you’ve Stumbled your way here, thanks much. I’d like to point out that this isn’t one of my strongest posts, and I’d encourage you to browse around. Check out:

  1. Too Big to Fail
  2. It’s Not Fascism When We Do It
  3. The Truth About What Anarchists Want
  4. Economies of Scale: The Faustian Bargain
  5. Exploitation: Immigrants and Slaves

And thanks for visiting, again!

Sometimes you hear this sort of argument: “This is America, if you don’t like it, pack your bags and leave.”

Of course the person making the argument always presumes that his beliefs are the only true “American” beliefs. The presumption in the “get the fuck out” argument is always that one’s own arguments are infallible. This is problematic, because the presumption can never be true: “America” is an abstract; at best it is a conglomeration of many, many diverse individuals with many divergent opinions and belief sets.

Now that we have concluded the presumption is never true, we need to take a long, hard look at the argument. Most proponents of this argument subscribe to some variation of a belief in “the land of the Free,” which is a good point from which to start. This is the land of the “free,” alright, if you don’t like what I’m doing with my freedom, how’s about you get the fuck out? If I don’t like social security, or welfare, or the war on terror, or a giant fucking wall on the Mexican border, I shouldn’t have to leave. You’re the one who wants it, after all. Feel free to exclude me from OASDI and AFDC benefits, hell, for all I care, build a fucking tunnel between my house and Mexico. Why do I have to leave?

Because, honestly, it sounds like it’s your problem – not mine.

+++

But really, the point I want to make, is that if you do believe in a land of the “free,” then ultimately nobody should ever be called upon to leave on account of someone else’s mere displeasure or disagreement. Just ignore the stuff that doesn’t affect you, associate with people with whom you share common ideals, goals, hobbies, beliefs, values, etc., and let everyone else do the same.

If you’re incapable of doing this, stop trying to tell people that you believe in freedom when you fucking hate its guts.

Comments

3 Comments

RSS
  • perlhaqr says on: July 17, 2008 at 8:15 pm

     

    But, usually the people I’m telling to get the fuck out are trying to take away some freedom of mine!

    (Most recently, in “discussions” of the Heller ruling. People lamenting that it was so horrible and we were all going to die because of icky guns.)

    And seriously. There’s well over a hundred other countries where the people can’t have guns. America is nearly unique in this regard. Leave me and my hobbies alone.

  • ryan says on: September 19, 2008 at 2:05 pm

     

    I agree but I feel that, especially following this coming election, we will have a certain population of Americans taking these people’s suggestion and “getting the fuck out” not because they bail on the ideals of this great country but rather because they feel that those ideals have been forsaken by the likes of whom you speak of and consequently feel threatened by the infringement on their personal freedoms and the consequences of similar ignorance. What do you think?

no third solution

Blogging about liberty, anarchy, economics and politics